Cell Damage Expressed as a Health Problem
An example to show the connection between cell damage and
observable illness in the person exposed might help in understanding
the problems posed by radionuclide (radioactive chemical)
uptake, i.e. their ingestion, inhalation or absorption with food, air and
water, into human bodies, with subsequent cell damage. The thyroid
gland contains cells which produce thyroid hormone, which when released
into the bloodstream causes the body functions such as breathing,
digesting and reacting to stress to proceed at a certain rate. If
the thyroid is `overactive', one might notice in the person increased
pulse rate, nervousness, excitability, loss of body weight and, in
females, more frequent menstruation. Such a person is often called
`hyperactive' (hyper-thyroidism). A normal amount of thyroid hormone
in the blood produces a normally active individual. An `underactive' or
`hypoactive' thyroid can result in sluggishness, listlessness, weight
gain and irregular and/or infrequent menstrual flow in women
(hypothyroidism).
If
radioactive iodine (I 131 or I 129) is ingested with food it will
enter the blood and tend to accumulate in the thyroid. Radioactive
iodine emits high-energy gamma radiation which can destroy thyroid
cells, thus reducing total thyroid hormone production in the individual
so affected.
A
small amount of radioactive iodine would probably kill only a few
cells and have little or no noticeable effect on health. However, if
many cells are destroyed or altered, the hormone level would
noticeably drop or the hormone itself would be slightly changed. The
individual would become lethargic and gain weight. If properly
diagnosed and severe enough to require medical intervention, this
hypoactive thyroid condition can be controlled with artificially
ingested thyroid hormone. A mild exposure experienced by a large
population could cause a decrease in average thyroid hormone levels
and an increase in average body weight, such as is occurring now in
the North American population. The USA has been polluted with
nuclear industries since 1943 and with radioactive iodine from weapon
testing since 1951. Radioactive iodine is routinely released in small
quantities by nuclear power plants and in large quantities by nuclear
reprocessing plants. It is not part of the natural human environment. The
connection between this pollution and the overweight problem
has, unfortunately, never been seriously researched. There is no
evidence to confirm or deny the hypothesis, but weight increase is a
well-known biological response to radioactive iodine. The hypothesis is
certainly plausible under the circumstances.
It
is possible for thyroid cells to be altered but not killed by the
radiation. The cellular growth mechanism may be damaged, allowing
a runaway proliferation of cells. This results in a thyroid tumour,
either cancerous (malignant), or non-cancerous (benign). Other
possible radiation damage includes changes in the chemical
composition of the individual's thyroid hormone, altering its action in
the body and causing clinically observable symptoms not easily
diagnosed or corrected.
There
is an extremely remote possibility that these changes will be
desirable, but the overall experience of randomly damaging a complex
organism like the human body is that it is destructive of health.
An
atomic veteran who participated in the nuclear tests which were
conducted by the USA in the Bikini atoll in the late 1940s reported
that he gained 75 lbs in the four years following his participation. The
doctor diagnosed his problem as hypothyroidism. He also suffered from
high blood pressure, chronic asthma and frequent bouts of bronchitis
and pneumonia. He has had six tumours diagnosed since 1949, when
he returned home from military service. Four have been surgically
removed.
Damage
to the thyroid of a developing foetus can cause mental
retardation and other severe developmental
anomalies.[15]
Other
radionuclides will lodge in other parts of the body. If the
trachea, bronchus or lung are exposed, the damage eventually causes
speech or respiratory problems. If radioactive particles lodge in the
stomach or digestive tract, the heart, liver, pancreas or other internal
organs or tissues, the health problems will be correspondingly different
and characteristic of the organ damaged. Radionuclides which lodge
in the bone marrow can cause leukaemia, depression of the immune
system (i.e. the body's ability to combat infectious diseases) or blood
diseases of various kinds.
If
the radiation dose is high, there is extensive cell damage and
health effects are seen immediately. Penetrating radiation doses at
1,000 rad or more cause `frying of the brain' with immediate brain
death and paralysis of the central nervous system. This is why no one
dared to enter the crippled Three Mile Island nuclear reactor building
during the 1979 accident. An average of 30,000 roentgens (or rads)
per hour were being reported by instruments within the containment
building. This would convert to a 1,000 rad exposure for two minutes
spent inside the building. Such a dose to the whole body is invariably
fatal.
The
radiation dose at which half the exposed group of people would
be expected to die, i.e. the 50 percent lethal dose, is 250 rad. The
estimate is somewhat higher if only young men in excellent health
(e.g. soldiers) are exposed. Between 250 and 1,000 rad,
death is usually due to gross damage to the stomach and gut. Below
250 rad death is principally due to gross damage to the bone marrow
and blood vessels. A dose of about 200 rad to a foetus in the womb is
almost invariably fatal.
Penetrating
radiation in doses above 100 rad inflicts severe skin
burns. Lower doses produce burns in some people. Vomiting and
diarrhoea are caused by doses above about 50 rad. There are some
individuals who are more sensitive to radiation, however, showing
typical vomiting and diarrhoea radiation sickness patterns with doses
as low as 5 rad. An individual may react differently at different times
of life or under different circumstances. Below 30 rad, for most
individuals, the effects from external penetrating radiation are not
immediately felt. The mechanism of cell damage is similar to that
described for minute quantities of radioactive chemicals which lodge
within the body itself, and our bodies are incapable of `feeling'
damage to or death of cells. Only when enough cells are damaged to
interfere with the function of an organ or a body system does the
individual become conscious of the problem.
By
sharpening our perceptions more subtle radiation effects can
often become observable where once they went unnoticed. For
example, a series of X-rays received by a young child may cause
temporary depression of the white blood cells, and ten days to two
weeks after the exposure the child will get influenza or some other
infectious disease. Ordinarily the parent views the two events as
unconnected.
Sometimes
one can observe a mutation in a person who has
experienced loss of hair after radiation therapy to kill tumour
cells: hair that was formerly very straight can be curly when
it grows again.
A
plant whose flowers are normally white with red tips but which
begins to form uniformly red flowers has mutated. Such an event has
been observed by persons living in the vicinity of Sellafield in the
United Kingdom.
The
use of radiation therapy to destroy malignant cells also has
observable results. It is rather like surgery in that it is deliberately
used to kill the unwanted tumour cells.
Probable Health Effects resulting
from Exposure to Ionising Radiation
Dose in rems
(whole body)
|
Health effects
Immediate
|
Delayed
|
|
1,000 or more
|
Immediate death.
`Frying of the brain'.
|
None
|
600-1,000
|
Weakness, nausea,
vomiting and
diarrhoea followed by
apparent
improvement. After
several days: fever,
diarrhoea, blood
discharge from the
bowels, haemorrhage
of the larynx, trachea,
bronchi or lungs,
vomiting of blood and
blood in the urine.
|
Death in about 10
days. Autopsy shows
destruction of
hematopoietic
tissues, including
bone marrow, lymph
nodes and spleen;
swelling and
degeneration of
epithelial cells of
the intestines,
genital organs and
endocrine glands.
|
250-600
|
Nausea, vomiting,
diarrhoea, epilation
(loss of hair),
weakness, malaise,
vomiting of blood,
bloody discharge from
the bowels or kidneys,
nose bleeding,
bleeding from gums
and genitals,
subcutaneous
bleeding, fever,
inflammation of the
pharynx and stomach,
and menstrual
abnormalities.
Marked destruction of
bone marrow, lymph
nodes and spleen
causes decrease in
blood cells especially
granulocytes and
thrombocytes.
|
Radiation-induced
atrophy of the
endocrine glands
including the
pituitary, thyroid
and adrenal glands.
From the third to
fifth week after
exposure, death is
closely correlated
with degree of
leukocytopenia. More
than 50% die in this
time period.
Survivors
experience keloids,
ophthalmological
disorders, blood
dyscrasis, malignant
tumours, and
psychoneurological
disturbances.
|
150-250
|
Nausea and vomiting
on the first day.
Diarrhoea and
probable skin burns.
Apparent
improvement for
about two weeks
thereafter.
Foetal or embryonic
death if pregnant.
|
Symptoms of malaise
as indicated above.
Persons in poor
health prior to
exposure, or those
who develop a
serious infection,
may not survive.
The healthy adult
recovers to somewhat
normal health in
about three months.
He or she may have
permanent health
damage, may develop
cancer or benign
tumours, and will
probably have a
shortened lifespan.
Genetic and
teratogenic effects.
|
50-150
|
Acute radiation
sickness and burns
are less severe than
at the higher
exposure dose.
Spontaneous abortion
or stillbirth.
|
Tissue damage
effects are less
severe. Reduction in
lymphocytes and
neutrophils leaves the
individual temporarily
very vulnerable to
infection. There may
be genetic damage to
offspring, benign or
malignant tumours,
premature ageing and
shortened lifespan.
Genetic and
teratogenic effects.
|
10-50
|
Most persons
experience little or no
immediate reaction.
Sensitive individuals
may experience
radiation sickness.
|
Transient effects in
lymphocytes and
neutrophils.
Premature ageing,
genetic effects and
some risk of tumours.
|
0-10
|
None
|
Premature ageing,
mild mutations in
offspring, some risk
of excess tumours.
Genetic and
teratogenic effects.
|
|